Friday, March 12, 2010 | 27 Rabi al-Awwal 1431  
The Musawah network
Claiming back Islam’s revolutionary spirit
On February 13, 2009, a group of 250 gathered in Kuala Lumpur for five intense days to challenge the unjust application of family law throughout the Muslim world. The movement that resulted - Musawah - represents an important initiative in the search for equality and justice in the Muslim family.
In the last decade the ideas of Islamic feminism have been gaining momentum across Muslim-majority countries and Muslim communities abroad. In response to the rise in religious fundamentalism on the one hand and political Islam on the other, feminist activists and scholars have been equipping themselves with a new tool – the original Islamic teachings and their alternative and progressive interpretations -- in order to advocate for women’s rights and promote equality and justice within the family. This trend has manifested itself in Algeria, Tunisia, Egypt, Malaysia, Morocco, Indonesia, Pakistan, India, and other countries.

What was clearly lacking, however, was a global knowledge-building network with a coherent direction, a core from which to share and disseminate strategies, scholarship and best practices.

That is why February 17, 2009 will go down as a memorable day in the history of Muslim feminism. It is the day when a groundbreaking movement, Musawah, was launched in the capital of Malaysia, Kuala Lumpur. Musawah ("equality" in Arabic) is a logical step forward and a very important initiative in the search for equality and justice in the Muslim family.

For five intense days, 250 women and men from 48 countries - activists, lawyers, scholars, politicians, journalists and bloggers - brainstormed strategies and exchanged experiences and ideas. I was privileged enough to be among the Musawah participants. All of the women I met – be they policymakers, grassroots activists, lawyers or academics – were highly articulate and passionate advocates of the cause. A lot of them were personally behind the efforts to reform family laws and elevate women’s status in their respective countries. Veiled and not, modern or traditional, those women represented the diversity of Muslim cultures and were complete opposites of the voiceless and oppressed images of Muslim women that dominate the mainstream Western media.

Participants at the Musawah meeting discussed the family laws and practices in many Muslim countries that remain unjust, especially in areas related to marriage, divorce, inheritance and custody. A lot of those laws are based on medieval views of the family, which see the husband as the main breadwinner and provider of the family and the wife’s role as subordinate to her husband. The Egyptian code of family laws, for example, dates back to the 1920s and was modeled on the Ottoman family laws. It continues to maintain the traditional patriarchal system. Although Muslim family laws vary from country to country, what they have in common is a second-class treatment of women within families, and broader rights and privileges assigned to men.

Meanwhile the reality of the twenty-first century is strikingly different. Women increasingly put in as many hours at work and sometimes are the only breadwinners (especially in post-conflict countries or countries with higher unemployment). In some sectors, women across Muslim countries enjoy a higher rate of employment than men. These figures are more visible in the Arab countries where women’s share of economic activity has recently grown more than 6 times the global rate.

The Musawah meeting put forward its Framework for Action, which is represented by the statement: "Equality and justice in the family are both necessary and possible." It is possible to achieve the change if we use a combination of arguments - those based on religious teachings, universal human rights declarations, national constitutions and, importantly, the reality of today’s life and women’s changing roles. The Musawah Framework quotes the Qur’an to prove its point that Islam calls for justice, equality, human dignity, love and compassion in relations among humans and in the family. "Family laws and practices must therefore fulfill this call by promoting these principles and responding to the lived realities of Muslim men and women today."

Backed by the expertise of the leading scholars on Islamic law such as Ziba Mir-Hosseini, Amira El-Azhary Sonbol and others, the Musawah statement argues that:
"most family laws and practices in today’s Muslim countries and communities are based on theories and concepts that were developed by classical jurists in vastly different historical, social and economic contexts. In interpreting the Qur’an and the Sunnah, classical jurists were guided by the social and political realities of their age and a set of assumptions about law, society and gender that reflected the state of knowledge, normative values and patriarchal institutions of their time. Gender equality was not part of their social experience. Hence it had no place in, and little relevance to, their conceptions of justice."
In practice, however, law reform and safeguarding the existing rights have proven to be an extremely hard battle for activists to win. Egyptian activists have been pushing for the reform of the Family Laws for decades with little result. Malaysian activists – led by the organisation Sisters In Islam – have been having hard time in their struggle against the polygamy and other practices that clearly favor men’s interests. Fortunately, there are a few positive cases. The success of the women’s movement in Morocco in pushing through the comprehensive reform of the Personal Status Code, the Moudawana, has been immensely inspirational to Muslim women activists around the world. Turkish women’s groups also successfully lobbied the pro-Islamic government to make necessary changes to the Civil and Criminal Codes. In both countries, the new laws describe men and women as equal partners in a marriage.

These struggles are the hardest and they require a lot of dedication, energy, knowledge and skill. Both religious institutions and state forces with a stake in preserving the patriarchal system will not give up their power easily. The global rise in conservative and fundamentalist Islam is threatening to take away the existing women’s rights even in countries with the constitutional guarantees of equality and secular family laws.

With the the birth of the Musawah network, Muslim feminist activists will feel more united and stronger than before. There is a special website which may turn into a forum for exchange of ideas and finding support, and a joint database is being put together.

The following words of Zainah Anwar, one of the leading coordinators and project director of the Musawah movement, reflect the inner belief cherished inside the hearts of activists and scholars gathered in Kuala-Lumpur: "It is our hope that Musawah as a global movement will lead to that day when those in the Muslim world will realise that women’s demands for equality and justice are neither alien nor a threat to Islam, but are rooted in the Islamic tradition." Yes, we do hope and will be working hard for that day.


Nadira Artyk is a Brooklyn-based women's rights advocate, journalist and media consultant. She was born and raised in Uzbekistan, Central Asia.



1 COMMENT ON THIS ARTICLE


Thanks for this article. I would also share that many American Muslim men, whether they are searching for new interpretations or studied through traditional chains of learning, have been increasingly revisiting interpretations of text as well. It is a disparate but growing movement, but what binds it is the search for the meaning behind the Arabic. The three letters that are the root of any conjugation are used to know the essence of a word. I think the result is “fundamental” but not “fundamentalist” as the term is used.

I am also aware of organizations like Karamah which studies women’s rights in the context of Islamic law.

But at least from my experience it seems like the general public in places like Pakistan might not be aware of these trends that are arising out of the West.



Page 1 of 1

ADD YOUR COMMENT
You must be logged in to leave comments.

Produced in
partnership with
See more of Altmuslimah's photographic campaign
Search altmuslimah


Subscribe to newsletter and feeds


Multimedia

Fashion Week: Malaysia (Vincent Thian/AP Photo, November 15, 2009)
iCover (Sadaf Syed, November 15, 2009)
Journeying through Oman (Lucy Marryat & Yoshi (Yusuf Misdaq), October 19, 2009)

Editors' blog

Conceptions of sexuality among American Muslim women - Ten AltMuslimah members/readers gathered on Sunday, February 21, 2010, with the goal of discussing the nature of Muslim women’s sexuality, and how American Muslim women’s social needs may be different. Whether formal or casual, the group agreed in the value of women’s support networks, especially considering the rising prevalence of domestic violence in our communities. A quick brainstorm of ideas brought up the possibility of periodic casual women’s nights, which are actually common in more active American Muslim communities. (March 1, 2010) (1 comment)

News briefs for week of March 1, 2010 - This week Washington, D.C. women storm the men’s section of a local mosque, a women in hijab is fired from her retail position in California, a women’s terrorist group is said to be uncovered in Egypt, Malaysia looks to hold a conference on women’s caning, Pakistani women’s clothing is highlighted, and Iran’s first female Olympic skier is profiled. (March 1, 2010) (0 comments)

News briefs for week of February 22, 2010 - Saudi religious police crackdown on Valentine's Day merchandise, Three Malaysian women are caned for extramarital sex, Saudi to permit female lawyers to argue cases, New Jersey Muslim man throws baby over a bridge, and Baltimore sixth-graders go on a field trip to an Islamic center. (February 22, 2010) (0 comments)

News briefs for week of February 15, 2010 - This week, death threats for dehijabing in Spain, a ballet showcasing Muslim women’s historical accomplishments, France continues the burqa ban debate, a Pakistani woman is recognized in California, Muslim scholars question full-body scanning and Obama names an envoy to the Muslim world. (February 15, 2010) (0 comments)

News briefs for week of February 8, 2010 - This week, a study finds that abstinence-focused sex education in American schools can persuade youth to delay sexual activity, sixteen-year-old Turkish girl buried alive for talking to boys, French authorities deny citizenship to man who forces his wife to wear a full veil, and female government leaders have done little to advance women's rights in Southeast and South Asia. (February 8, 2010) (2 comments)

News briefs for week of February 1, 2010 - This week stress on female virginity is put on blast, a women’s rights book is allowed onto Malaysian shelves, and the burqa debate continues in France and Denmark. (February 1, 2010) (0 comments)

Readers' blog

Will you be my (halal) Valentine? - Why does Valentine’s Day spark such contentious debate among American Muslims across blogs and social networking sites? What underlying emotional buttons does this commercialized cultural holiday push among American Muslims? While other holidays, such as Mother’s Day and Father’s Day, generate a few tired and tepid discussions centered around the idea that “everyday should be Mother’s and Father’s Day,” Valentine’s Day, like the very concept of romantic love it celebrates, generates much more passionate responses. These debates touch on many topics including what love means or should mean to Muslims, the relationship between culture and religion, and the current state of romantic relationships among Muslims. (February 22, 2010) (1 comment)

Living up to the legacy - By historical account, being a Muslim female meant being virtuous, loving, knowledgeable, and empowered by her faith. Well it’s centuries later and although we cite to the legacy of Islam, we fail to live up to it or keep the legacy alive. (February 4, 2010) (1 comment)

Bridging literacy and cultural gaps in Pakistan - In addition to bridging cultural and socioeconomic gaps, the American International School System in Pakistan acts as an experimental model and incubator by incorporating some of the education reform principles advocated by grassroots organizations, education specialists and writers, and governmental agencies like the Ministry of Education. (January 3, 2010) (1 comment)

Islam and manhood - The infamy of Islamist terrorism over the past decade has created an image of the Muslim man as intrinsically prone to violent behavior, even if directed toward the self rather than the other. The image of the angry, flag-burning, chanting Muslim man has come to symbolize male violence. However the photos fail to explain that, firstly, the anger, in many instances, is justified, secondly, that the chants rarely spill over into to physical violence, and thirdly that violence is not exclusive to Muslim men. (December 25, 2009) (5 comments)

It’s not about the niqab, it’s about credibility - The question, which we all should consider now is why Al-Azhar scholars are not obeyed by the public any more? The simple and direct answer to this very complicated question is because Al-Azhar lost its credibility in the eyes of Egyptians. (October 17, 2009) (4 comments)

One woman’s journey toward pleasing Allah - Understanding the purpose and reasoning behind abaya is not something a Muslim girl learns the day she is born. For many, like myself, it was a slow and steady journey; one that required much research and reflection. (September 25, 2009) (4 comments)

Founder & Editor-In-Chief
Asma T. Uddin

Executive Editor
Zahed Amanullah

Publisher
Shahed Amanullah

Associate Editors
Fatima Bahloul
Rabea Chaudhry
Fatemeh Fakhraie
Abbas Jaffer
Sarah Jawaid
Anjum Malkana
Enith Morillo
Shazia Riaz
Zehra Rizavi

Contributors
Uzma Mariam Ahmed
Fatima Ayub
Jack Fairweather
Hussein Rashid
Sarah Uddin
Rahilla Zafar
Rafia Zakaria
Our mission | Our partners| In the news | Contact us | Submit an article | Advertising