Friday, September 03, 2010 | 24 Ramadan 1431  
War
Rape for ethnic cleansing
To the victor go the spoils is the concept that has been used over history to legitimize wartime rape. This tradition of objectifying women during conflicts has not ceased during modern times. Despite the introduction of modern laws of warfare, armies exploit sexual violence systematically as in the cases of the former Yugoslavia, Rwanda and the current situation in Darfur.
Rape has been disregarded in conflict situations for a variety of reasons. For example, oftentimes soldiers guilty of raping the enemy’s women did not face prosecution because rape was considered a tool of war ; it served to feminize the enemy and break the spirits of the fighting troops or it served as a means to boost troop morale. The repeated and unpunished use of rape in wartime only highlights the importance of the International Criminal Tribunal’s resolution for the former Yugoslavia (ICTY) which considers wartime rape tantamount to a crime of genocide. This complements the earlier role of the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda (ICTR) which stated that rape is a crime against humanity. The gravity of the Rwanda genocide shocked the world’s conscience and pressured nations towards a full acknowledgment of the horrors endured by these women. However, the same spirit remains absent in the case of Darfur.

In social theory it is becoming commonplace to recognize rape as a manifestation of power rather than of sexual desire. Wartime rape is no exception and organized rape in conflict takes various forms. The first is sexual enslavement in which women are kidnapped and detained in confinement centers where they are forced to satisfy the sexual desires of the army men, as well as tend to housekeeping duties such as cooking and laundry. It is noteworthy that these women are rarely of the same nationality or ethnic group as the predators. The second type of sexual violation is mass rape with intent to humiliate and murder as in the case of the Nanking Rape, an incident in which the Japanese Imperial Army raped and killed more than 20,000 Chinese women. The Rwandan case offers the third type of sexual violation; here rape carries the intent of genocide. Hutu fighters raped and killed Tutsi women during the Rwandan war, systematically using rape and murder to eliminate the Tutsi ethnicity.

When compared to other cases of mass rape, such as those which took place in Rwanda, the Bosnian case is distinctive both in its intent as well as its legal consequences. In the Bosnian case, much like the Darfurian case, sexual violence was used as a tool of terror to induce forced displacement. The Serbian army used rape systematically, coupled with other methods like male concentration camps and group murder, to create a pure Serbian state. The historical as well as the political development of the former Yugoslavia can explain the escalation of the ethnic tension between the religious groups. Such tension led to the rise of strong nationalistic inclinations especially for Serbia, the most dominant of the Yugoslav states. This is similar to Sudan’s multi-ethnic heritage, where a series of civil conflicts started in 1955 were fueled by a long history of ethnic and racial tension. In the Darfurian case, using sexual violence in a tribal community that guards female sexuality as part of the collective honor not only serves as a tool of terror, but also as a method of humiliation.

Unlike rapes in Bosnia, the mass rapes in Darfur went ignored by the international community. United Nations-African Union Mission in Darfur (UNAMID) reports 72 cases of rape in its 90 days of monitoring in 2009. It takes little math to estimate the number of women raped and sexually violated since the start of the conflict in 2004. Human rights NGOs estimate higher numbers of unreported cases due to the stigma of rape in the tribal cultural context, in order words, the victims prefer to deny rape rather than report it for fear of social ostracization and rejection by their own families.

The International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia passed resolutions which criminalized the use of sexual violence as a tool of terror and ethnic cleansing. This is a step forward in the progress of humanitarian law in both scope and practice. The statute of the ICTY extended the definition of crimes against humanity to include rape, thus agreeing with the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda’s rule on the subject as both courts allowed for international intervention to protect civilians in internal conflicts. In practice, the Furundazija case set new parameters for the prosecution of rape. It states in detail the types of sexual violations that constitute rape, unlike the vague terms used in earlier tribunals. Anton Furundazija was the local commander of a special unit of the military police of the Croatian Defense Council (HVO) known as the "Jokers." In his capacity as head of the “Jokers,” he and another member of the militia were interrogating two Bosniaks, a woman and a male friend of hers. In Frunidazija’s presence, the other soldier sexually abused the women by rubbing a knife on her lower stomach and inner thigh with threats to cut her from inside. Then, the soldier forced the woman to have vaginal and oral sex with him while her friend watched. Being in the position of leadership, Furundazijia was required to intervene. As a result of his inaction, he was condemned for rape as he shared the same intention of using physical, emotional and sexual abuse to humiliate the victims.

The progress of international law as seen in the ICTY and the ICTR is praise worthy. Nonetheless, the rapes of Darfur are yet to be judged and the suffering of the women of Darfur remains to be acknowledged. To this day, none of the named perpetrators has been brought to justice. The failure of the international community to recognize and heal the pain of the victims is a shameful blemish on the world’s conscience.

Reham Hussain has worked as an advocate for refugees psychosocial rights in Cairo and has worked with victims of sexual violence and abuse. She is currently working on her thesis on refugee's access to HIV/AIDS services in Egypt at the Center of Migration and Refugee Studies at the American University in Cairo.
ZERO COMMENTS ON THIS ARTICLE

ADD YOUR COMMENT
You must be logged in to leave comments.

Produced in
partnership with

Founder & Editor-In-Chief
Asma T. Uddin

Executive Editor
Zahed Amanullah

Publisher
Shahed Amanullah

Associate Editors
Sarah Jawaid
Anjum Malkana
Zehra Rizavi

Multimedia Editor
Fatima Bahloul

Contributing Editors
Fatemeh Fakhraie
Abbas Jaffer

Events and Publicity
Shazia Riaz

Support Altmuslimah


Search altmuslimah


Subscribe to newsletter and feeds




See more of Altmuslimah's photographic campaign

NISI Fashion (Anisa Noormohamed , April 10, 2010)
Episode Four: Headscarf (Crystal Quallo, March 19, 2010)
Fashion Week: Malaysia (Vincent Thian/AP Photo, November 15, 2009)


News briefs for week of August 23, 2010 - This week, A Bangladesh court ruled that people cannot be forced to wear religious clothing, a youth organization in Massachusetts urges officials for more comprehensive cultural sensitivity training of teachers, Emirati women frequent hair salons less during the month of Ramadan, and the Christian Science Monitor describes the pro-women's rights stance of one of the leaders behind the proposed Islamic center near ground zero. (August 24, 2010) (0 comments)

News briefs for week of August 16, 2010 - This week, the government of Afghanistan releases statistics on alarmingly high suicide attempt rates by Afghan women, and an Islamic theologian recounts his experience on a nudist beach that led to his conversion to Islam. (August 17, 2010) (0 comments)

Ramadan: A wife’s perspective (and a husband’s) - When my husband finally makes his way down the stairs, my frustration abates and he and I sit across from each other and share our early morning meal. We speak intermittently and keep one eye trained on the clock to ensure we finish our food by the time dawn prayers begin. Despite the sparse conversation and the hurried meal, I enjoy the feeling that we are both beginning our obligatory fasts together, as a unit. (August 13, 2010) (1 comment)

News briefs for week of August 9, 2010 - This week in the news, why pregnant women exempt from fasting still fast, Taliban responds to TIME's cover story on Aisha, Satirist claims he is not joking about his plans to open an Islamic gay bar next to Cordoba Mosque, and a young American Muslim man abstains from alcohol and dating for the month of Ramadan. (August 10, 2010) (0 comments)

News briefs for week of August 2, 2010 - Brazil offers asylum to Iranian women sentenced to death by stoning, veiled women pass through Canadian airport checkpoint without being checked, Malaysian reality show crowns its champion imam, and a few British gay Muslims find support from their local imams. (August 3, 2010) (0 comments)

News Briefs for the week of July 24, 2010 - This week, Saudi clerics seek more Muslim maids and say its okay for women to uncover their faces in the presence of burqa bans. Two French women in burqinis were refused entry into a pool, and two Muslim women in England are not allowed onto a public bus. (July 27, 2010) (0 comments)

Intern Icon

Founder & Editor-In-Chief
Asma T. Uddin

Executive Editor
Zahed Amanullah

Publisher
Shahed Amanullah

Associate Editors
Sarah Jawaid
Anjum Malkana
Zehra Rizavi

Multimedia Editor
Fatima Bahloul

Contributing Editors
Fatemeh Fakhraie
Abbas Jaffer
Events and Publicity
Shazia Riaz
Our mission | Our partners| In the news | Contact us | Submit an article | Advertising