Friday, July 30, 2010 | 19 Shaaban 1431  
First ladies
Is “Michelle Obama” a new brand?


Nowadays, news agencies – mostly American- are trying to enforce a new feminine ideal.
“The deafening cheers were not for presidential hopeful Mir Hossein Mousavi, but rather for his wife — a woman some are calling Iran’s Michelle Obama.

The comparisons to the first lady of the United States stem from the role Zahra Rahnavard is playing in her husband’s quest for the presidency.

Never in the history of Iranian presidential elections has a candidate put his wife in the forefront of his campaign.”
Is Michelle Obama a new brand marking every well-spoken woman in the world? Maybe they assume she’s an original Adidas, and these other women her Chinese copies.

There are actually no parallels between Zahra Rahnavard and Michelle Obama. They’re two different people with two different identities.

If Barack Obama wasn’t president, nobody would notice the fashionable, well-spoken, and smart Michelle Obama. Despite all her smartness and style, she would remain in the world of unknowns. Her fame is attributable entirely to her husband’s success.

Compare: many in Iran knew Zahra Rahnavard before they know Mir Hussein Mussavi. Her husband is using her fame to further his campaign. There are many Iranians who vote for Mir Hussain Mussavi just because of his wife, Iran’s first female university chancellor after the Iranian Revolution, with over 30 books to her credit.

Rahnavard is also famous for being a political adviser to a former Iranian president and for her sculptures in several of Tehran’s famous squares.

She is not famous for fashion, because she wears the black chador, though she has never practiced the Mantou dress-code. She wears a long sleeve shirt and pants under her black chador. And, in keeping with Iranian law, she has not changed her surname after marriage - probably the one thing she does have in common with Michelle Obama.

That’s what writers who compare these two women fail to comprehend. Every nation has its special identity. An Iranian remains Iranian. A Muslim woman represents the ideal of her own people.

An intelligent and well-spoken Muslim woman does not need an American brand, because she is her own unique brand -- an independent woman with her own identity, culture and beliefs. Queen Rania of Jordan is, similarly, a brand of her own, just like Shaikha Muzah, Queen of Qatar. None of them are American and certainly none of them can and want to be compared with an American ideal.

Maybe it’s Michelle Obama who is America’s Zahra Rahnavard.



2 COMMENTS ON THIS POST


Lol, this is kind of funny. It is a question of who is what brand, which isn’t so simple when many of us are immigrants. When we go overseas, people in our own countries say that we are Americans. Also, I believe some of the royalty in the Middle East don’t always represent their “brands”. I like Queen Noor, but if I remember correctly, she was considered too extravagant at one point.

I don’t know if I entirely agree with this article. Michelle has achieved quite a bit in her own rite, even if it is not 30 books. Benazir Bhutto also achieved quite a bit, and she was also smart, well-spoken, and fashionable. Yet Michelle has a more loyal following where Bhutto’s was mixed.

The question of who has legitimacy among their people also becomes distorted by non-native influences.



Well, in my country Mrs. Obama is more familiar than Mrs. Rahnavard, but as a muslima, I believe that Mrs. Rahnavard is a super-great woman, although I just knew her from your article. I’d love to read more articles about her.



Page 1 of 1

ADD YOUR COMMENT
You must be logged in to leave comments.

Produced in
partnership with

See more of Altmuslimah's photographic campaign

Support Altmuslimah


Search altmuslimah


Subscribe to newsletter and feeds


Multimedia

NISI Fashion (Anisa Noormohamed , April 10, 2010)
Episode Four: Headscarf (Crystal Quallo, March 19, 2010)
Fashion Week: Malaysia (Vincent Thian/AP Photo, November 15, 2009)

The altmuslimah team

Founder & Editor-In-Chief
Asma T. Uddin

Executive Editor
Zahed Amanullah

Publisher
Shahed Amanullah

Associate Editors
Rabea Chaudhry
Sarah Jawaid
Anjum Malkana
Zehra Rizavi

Multimedia Editor
Fatima Bahloul

Contributing Editors
Fatemeh Fakhraie
Abbas Jaffer

Events and Publicity
Enith Morillo
Shazia Riaz

Editors' blog

News Briefs for the week of July 24, 2010 - This week, Saudi clerics seek more Muslim maids and say its okay for women to uncover their faces in the presence of burqa bans. Two French women in burqinis were refused entry into a pool, and two Muslim women in England are not allowed onto a public bus. (July 27, 2010) (0 comments)

News briefs for week of July 19, 2010 - Syria bans niqabs on university campuses, NPR interviews female imams in China, and Spain rejects burqa ban. (July 21, 2010) (0 comments)

News Briefs for the week of July 10, 2010 - This week, a British parliamentarian gets on the anti-burqa bandwagon, A French businessman seeks to pay all burqa fines imposed in France, building of a mosque in California is heavily opposed, and a woman judge is appointed to Malaysia’s Islamic Court. (July 12, 2010) (0 comments)

Reporting from Kashmir: Restless nights of inner and outer noise - These women would not stand down. They stood together, young and old, fueled by grief and craving to be heard. The army sat across the street, staring them down while they kept shouting “Azaadi, Azaadi,” (Freedom, Freedom). (July 8, 2010) (0 comments)

Reporting from Kashmir: My pen is my mace - I spoke to some of the women and their enthusiasm for journalism was inspiring. They shared that it was difficult for them to break into it because it tends to be a boy’s club. But they continue writing because they are “passionate” about it. (July 6, 2010) (0 comments)

Reporting from Kashmir: An abode of saints - After my INTACH meeting, we met up with the founder of the HELP foundation, the luminous, Nighat Shafi. She gave us an overview of all of her work, creating a home for mentally disabled children, widows, and schools. Her team also talked about their work in villages, providing grants for job training and scholarship. (July 6, 2010) (0 comments)

Intern Icon

Singles Ad

Founder & Editor-In-Chief
Asma T. Uddin

Executive Editor
Zahed Amanullah

Publisher
Shahed Amanullah

Associate Editors
Rabea Chaudhry
Sarah Jawaid
Anjum Malkana
Zehra Rizavi

Multimedia Editor
Fatima Bahloul

Contributing Editors
Fatemeh Fakhraie
Abbas Jaffer
Events and Publicity
Enith Morillo
Shazia Riaz
Our mission | Our partners| In the news | Contact us | Submit an article | Advertising